Cat Burgler Black by Richard Sala

Title: Cat Burgler Black
Author: Richard Sala
Illustrator: Richard Sala
Publisher: First Second (:01)
Copyright: 2009
Price: $16.99
ISBN: 978-1-59643-144-7
-----------
Summary and Quick Thoughts: Katherine “K.” Westree may finally have a home and some family. As an orphan, she grew up in an orphanage where she was trained to be a cat burglar, but she hopes to leave that all behind. Unfortunately, her aunt is ill, leaving her to do the deeds of the questionable head mistress. Readers will follow “K” as she performs to the task only to see demons from her past. Sala presents a book with more telling than showing with average artwork, plot holes, and yet a compelling story about K.
---------
Will Teens Like It? Questionable. Teens may be turned off by the huge amounts of text
--------
Things to be aware of: Nothing. This is clean except for the topic of burglary and even that is frowned upon.
----------
Longer Thoughts: Cat Burglar Black made it to my desk because the children’s department did not think it was appropriate for their area (at my previous gig). I have to agree, yet it does work for a middle school crowd. More or less, this is the story about K, who just wants to leave burglary behind and enjoy life. She is forced into stealing again, but does what she’s told because she believes it is what her Aunt wants.

Richard Sala’s art is simplistic and a few times I questioned why he used certain perspectives, which jarred me out of the story. In panels where characters were running, I often thought they were just walking quickly. The art, as delightful and different as it is, does not convey the actions he wants to convey. There is also too much text in places. Some panels are just a person’s head and shoulders and the rest is text. To me, the point of a graphic novel is to show, not tell, and feel more like a movie in my head than a book in my hands. Lastly, there are a lot of open plot points involving the characters from the aunt (where was she throughout the story?) to the groundskeeper (I know he’s important, but how?). The ending neatly ties up the story, but hints at the possibility for more.

Cat Burglar Black can be a compelling read, but only for those not familiar with graphic novels and who possibly want to see what the genre is. Unfortunately, it is not really a good representation of the genre.

One last thing: the review on the back by Lemony Snicket is not helpful in the least. It is an alphabetical listing of one to three word phrases that supposedly describe the book. When I realized it was an alphabet, it became clear that it really did not give a review of the book.
------
Bonus:  ALA 2010 Great Graphic Novel
------
Source: Library copy