Title: Happy Marriage?! (vol. 1-10, series recap)Author: Maki Enjoji
Illustrator: Maki Enjoji
Publisher: Viz Media, Inc.
Copyright: 2013-2015 (Japanese 2009)
Price: $9.99 each
ISBN: Vol. 1: 978-1-4215-5934-6
-----------
Summary and Quick Thoughts: Chiwa Takanashi is working two jobs to pay off her father's debts. By day, she's a secretary at Mamiya Corporation and at night, she's a hostess. To help Chiwa, the Chiarman of Mamiya offers her a deal: marry his grandson and all the debts will be erased. Seems legit, but then she finds out he's the jerk that got her fired from her hostess job the night before. Oh, and he's the company president.
Hokuto Mamiya has his own reasons to work up the ladder of Mamiya Coporation. Part of that has to do with the death of his mother by a hit and run. Hokuto is convinced that the Mamiya family is behind it somehow and will stop at nothing to find out what happened. So if the Chairman, his grandfather, wants him to marry a secretary he doesn't know, so be it.
In 10 volumes, the story covers their on again, off again relationship, how they navigate this semi-arranged marriage and their insecurities, which both have. The story is from Chiwa's perspective. Every volume has a fight that has someone walking out or slamming a door and the mystery of Hokuto is a strong subplot.
---------
Recommended Audience: Adults
--------
Things to be aware of: sex, druinkeness, emotional abuse, nudity (female)
----------
Further Thoughts:I am not an avid romance reader. See my note below on that, but if I was a romance reader, I'd say this reads like a romance. Mostly.
It was the last volume that killed it for me and I'll get into that in a bit. The series starts out strong enough for a romantic comedy: Chiwa is innocent and a virgin. He's the head of a company and the heartthrob in the story. How does Chiwa get to have him? For the first three to five volumes, they keep their marriage a secret from the other employees Chiwa works with (but of course, he tells the WORLD). Then she considers fooling around with an old love interest and decides to work for him because Hokuto isn't supportive of her being a housewife, which she only became because she didn't feel he supported her work, not to mention he's an idiot and works himself to exhaustion so Chiwa feels responsible to keep him healthy. Also, she's a neat freak and he's not.
The plot almost always follows the same cycle: they keep secrets, it escalates, one of them passes out/gets drunk/ticks the other one off/a side character reveals a secret, they fight, they promise to be open to each other and then it starts all over again.
Chiwa is a typical manga heroine: curvy, shoulder length hair, relatively good dresser, and shorter than the hero. She has her moments as a strong heroine, but more often than not her insecurity gets in her way and she's wondering: am I the perfect wife to Hokuto? If only she could help Hokuto. If only he would LET her help. Really, by the end of the series, I really don't know much about her likes or dislikes and she felt flat as a character (compared to Midnight Secretary which I was reading at the same time and in a way, has a slightly similar plot). Even the Christmas story illustrated that the only gift she wants is whatever makes him happy. Although, he does pick up that she might like a personal island.
Hokuto is the brooding hero and he's handsome as is expected in manga. He has the eyes, the dark hair, is tall, broad shoulders, well dressed, and he's got all the right lines (I'm talking muscles here). Honestly, he's a jerk more often than not by the end of the series. On the flip side, he's a wounded guy. He's strongest as a character when he protects Chiwa from a stalker, opens up to her about his real motivations for what he does with Mamiya Corporation (after she finds out from someone else he's done something like stepped down from Commerce) and he's patient enough to wait for her to be ready for sex (which happens in volume 3 or 4. The sex is so "hot" that a lot of the volumes I purchased were plastic wrapped. Fact: The sex in the Midnight Secretary, seemed hotter and was not plastic wrapped).
Let's talk about the sex a little. It's steamy in places. It's just the right amount of romantic. The most you see is what you'd see in movies, but there are at least two or three times I'm kind of concerned about the characters. He has drunk sex with her and doesn't realize it until half way through. I'm certain there is a borderline rape at least once where she says "NO" but he pushes the right buttons and she gives in. I always find fault with these kinds of scenes regardless if it is a movie, book, or comic, because I honestly don't know how I should feel about it.
There's also a few instances where he hits her. She hits him a few times too (like as part of the drunk sex scene because he really is like "Oh, hey, I didn't realize I was having sex"), but as a Goodreads Reviewer did note: he hits her to calm her down. He doesn't talk her down, he just slaps her face and she doesn't bat an eyelash. She blinks and seems calmed down enough to listen to him. UGH.
So you think by volume ten, the end of the series, they'd get what it was to be in a relationship. No. I had realized by volume eight that every volume had the same formula. Although, from eight to ten where the stuff with the family starts to come to light (the most interesting part at this point and the only reason I was still reading), we had the requisite "where'd the hero go?" Chiwa acted like her life was over. She cleaned her Dad's place and went back to attempt to help his lazy self. She worked (I think. I was getting bored with the series and really just wanted the subplot). She thought about Hokuto, but he had to go find himself. So, she'd be true and wait for him. UGH.
The last volume came along, I read it twice, and was really disappointed in how the characters had NOT grown. It was such a let down that the same patterns from earlier just continued: keeping secrets, a side character points out the secret, they fight. I was not convinced that these characters loved each other and I really didn't think they should be together in the end.
On the flip side of all of this, I know that Japanese culture is different. For example, working to exhaustion is a real problem and is used often in manga. Regarding relationships, I'm not sure what is permitted or not, but seeing how I've read a lot of romance-ish manga, this relationship was an odd one.
Overall feeling: The first few volumes are a quirky, romantic comedy and enjoyable. After the halfway point though, elements of abuse start to sneak in and can make the reader uncomfortable. It was the first time I didn't feel the characters "grow" in a manga title. I only own up to volume 7 with no intent to purchase more. There are better new adult manga titles out there.
--------------
Note: I am not an avid romance reader and by that, I'm mostly talking about the trade paperbacks/Harlequin's. The only one I've successfully loved in that genre of romance is J.D. Robb. On the other hand, I've had my fair education on romance novels and the plot. I defended romances in college in Gothic Lit and did some research then. This book started to fit the romance genre and then went somewhere else entirely. If you're a romance reader, please weigh in at the comments below!
--------------
Source: I purchased 1-2 and read volumes 3-10 from Edleweiss (an then purchased some of those).
No comments:
Post a Comment